We built this together: The psychology of belonging and brand loyalty

What makes someone choose the same mascara for five years straight? Why do beauty lovers wait in virtual queues for product launches from brands they've never even tried? The answer isn't just about formulas or packaging—it's about something far more powerful: the fundamental human need to belong.

In the beauty industry, where 95% of sales from Ulta come from participants in its loyalty program, the most successful brands have cracked the code on something psychologists have known for decades: people don't just buy products, they buy into communities.

The science behind beauty brand attachment

Brand attachment significantly enhances brand loyalty, willingness to pay a premium, and forgiveness toward the brand. But what creates this attachment in the first place? It comes down to three psychological drivers that smart beauty brands leverage every day.

Identity Expression: Beauty products serve as tools for self-expression and confidence-building. When you choose a brand that aligns with your values—whether that's cruelty-free testing, clean ingredients, or inclusive shade ranges—you're not just buying a product. You're making a statement about who you are and what you stand for.

Social Proof in Action: 84% of customers trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations, which explains why beauty brands invest heavily in user-generated content. When you see someone who looks like you achieving results you want, that brand instantly feels more trustworthy and relevant.

Psychological Ownership: The most loyal beauty customers are those who feel like they've played a role in the brand's journey. Whether it's voting on new shades, sharing feedback that leads to product improvements, or being part of exclusive launch experiences, engaging consumers via user-generated content or participatory campaigns fosters a sense of ownership, deepening loyalty.

Why community beats discount every time

Traditional loyalty programs focused on points and discounts are quickly becoming outdated. 53% of customers who return for a second purchase go on to make a third, and loyal existing customers have a 67% higher average order value than new customers. But here's the twist: the brands achieving these numbers aren't doing it through price cuts—they're building genuine communities.

Take Sephora's Beauty Insider program. Yes, it has points and tiers, but what really drives loyalty is the community aspect. Members don't just earn rewards for purchases—they earn them for engaging with content, attending virtual events, and sharing their experiences. By facilitating a sense of belonging and promoting meaningful interactions, you can establish an emotional connection that fosters loyalty and advocacy.

The psychology here is straightforward: when people feel like they belong to something bigger than themselves, they become invested in its success. Your wins become their wins. Your struggles become challenges they want to help you overcome.

The authenticity factor: why realness wins

In today's socially conscious climate, consumers are increasingly looking for brands that align with their values and beliefs. But here's where many brands get it wrong—they focus on what they think customers want to hear rather than who they authentically are.

The most powerful community-building happens when brands are vulnerably honest about their journey, their mistakes, and their learning process. BYBI, a direct-to-consumer skincare company, has grown by including its customers on its journey and even sources product ideas from Instagram comments and community trends.

This transparency creates what psychologists call "authentic relationships"—the kind where people feel genuinely connected rather than marketed to. When your community feels like they're part of your story rather than just consumers of your products, they become emotionally invested in your success.

Building belonging: the framework that works

Creating a community-driven beauty brand isn't about having the biggest social media following or the flashiest campaigns. It's about implementing systems that make people feel seen, valued, and connected. Here's how the most successful beauty brands do it:

Start With Shared Values: Identifying and promoting core values that resonate with your target audience, such as sustainability, inclusivity, or innovation, creates a sense of belonging and purpose among your customer base. Your values become the foundation that attracts like-minded people and gives them a reason to rally around your brand.

Create Two-Way Conversations: The days of one-way brand messaging are over. For beauty brands, aside from quality products, this loyalty is contingent on companies creating two-way conversations with customers, incentivising them with rewards and cultivating the feeling that they have a stake in the businesses. Ask for feedback, respond to comments, share behind-the-scenes content, and most importantly—act on the input you receive.

Reward Engagement, Not Just Purchases: Rather than just giving out loyalty points for making purchases, you can incentivise all sorts of behavior. Reward social media engagement, product reviews, referrals, and community participation. When people feel valued for more than just their wallet, they become more invested in the relationship.

Make Exclusivity Meaningful: Everyone wants to feel special, but not everyone can afford luxury prices. Create tiers of exclusivity based on engagement rather than just spending. Early access to new products, behind-the-scenes content, or input on future launches can feel more valuable than discounts to the right community members.

The multiplier effect: when customers become advocates

The most powerful aspect of community-driven beauty brands is what happens when customers become genuine advocates. Those that they refer are 4x more likely to make a purchase based on their recommendation. But this only happens when the advocacy feels natural rather than incentivized.

True advocates don't just buy your products—they defend your brand in comment sections, create content featuring your products without being asked, and actively recruit their friends because they genuinely believe in what you're building.

This level of advocacy can't be bought or manufactured. It only emerges when people feel a genuine sense of ownership and belonging within your community.

Your community strategy starts now

The beauty industry is moving away from transactional relationships toward genuine community building. By combining transactional rewards with a strong emphasis on community and emotional engagement, merchants can build loyalty programs that not only drive sales but create a deeper, more meaningful connection that keeps them coming back for more.

The brands that will thrive in the next decade won't just have great products—they'll have communities of people who feel genuinely connected to the brand's mission and to each other. These communities become self-sustaining ecosystems where belonging creates loyalty, loyalty drives advocacy, and advocacy fuels growth.

The question isn't whether community-driven marketing works in beauty—it's whether you're ready to build something bigger than just a product line. Because in a world where consumers have infinite choices, the brands that make people feel like they truly belong will always win.

Ready to build a beauty brand that creates genuine community and lasting loyalty?

START FREE