How to create a rewards program that turns beauty clients into lifelong advocates

95% of Ulta's sales come from loyalty program members. Sephora's Beauty Insider has over 31 million U.S. members who drive 90% of total sales. These aren't just statistics—they're proof that in the beauty industry, rewards programs aren't optional anymore. They're the difference between surviving and thriving.

But here's what most beauty entrepreneurs get wrong: they think rewards programs are about discounts. The brands seeing explosive growth understand that the best beauty loyalty programs are about relationships, not transactions. They're about creating communities where customers feel valued, heard, and excited to participate in something bigger than themselves.

Whether you're an aesthetician looking to deepen client relationships or a beauty brand owner wanting to increase customer lifetime value, this guide will show you exactly how to build a rewards program that transforms one-time buyers into passionate advocates.

Understanding the beauty customer mindset

Beauty purchases are deeply personal. When someone chooses your skincare routine or makeup products, they're not just buying items, they're investing in how they want to feel about themselves. This emotional connection is why beauty loyalty programs can be so powerful when done right.

The trust factor: In beauty, customer loyalty is earned through results and relationships. Over 80% of consumers say that being part of a loyalty program influences their decision to return to a brand. But the connection runs deeper, customers stick around because they’ve developed trust and routines with products that truly work for their unique needs.

Community over transactions: 81% of customers prefer companies that offer a personalized experience. But personalization isn't just about product recommendations, it's about making customers feel like valued community members rather than anonymous transaction numbers.

The repeat purchase reality: Beauty products are consumable, which means your best customers will naturally return every few months. A well-designed rewards program doesn't just encourage these repeat purchases, it makes them feel special and anticipated rather than routine.

The foundation: choosing your program type

Before diving into points and perks, you need to understand which type of loyalty program aligns with your business model and customer base.

Points-based programs: Perfect for beauty brands with frequent purchases and varied price points. Customers earn points for every dollar spent and can redeem them for products or experiences. Ulta's program exemplifies this approach, customers earn points that function like actual currency, giving them flexibility in how they redeem rewards.

Tiered programs: Ideal for brands wanting to encourage increased spending and create aspirational goals. Sephora's three-tier system (Insider, VIB, Rouge) works because each level offers genuinely valuable benefits that customers want to achieve. The key is ensuring each tier feels meaningfully different from the others.

Value-based programs: Great for brands with strong community elements. These programs reward customers for behaviors beyond purchasing, like reviews, referrals, and social media engagement. Beauty brand Blume uses this approach effectively, rewarding customers for activities that strengthen their community.

Hybrid approaches: The most successful beauty loyalty programs combine elements from multiple types. They offer points for purchases, tiers for different spending levels, and rewards for community engagement. This comprehensive approach maximizes both customer value and business impact.

Building your program structure

Step 1: Define your goals. Start with what you want to achieve. Are you looking to increase purchase frequency, boost average order value, improve customer retention, or build a stronger community? Your goals should directly influence your program design. For example, if community building is a priority, weight your rewards toward social engagement and referrals rather than just purchases.

Step 2: Understand your customer journey. Map out how customers currently interact with your brand. When do they make repeat purchases? What causes them to try new products? Where do they need encouragement or support? Your rewards program should enhance this natural journey rather than fight against it.

Step 3: Choose your earning structure. The most successful beauty loyalty programs use multiple earning opportunities:

• Purchase points: 1 point per dollar spent is standard, but consider bonus multipliers for new product launches or slower sales periods
• Engagement points: Reward social media follows, reviews, referrals, and newsletter sign-ups
• Milestone bonuses: Extra points for reaching spending thresholds or program anniversaries
• Surprise rewards: Unexpected bonuses that delight customers and encourage continued engagement

Step 4: Design your reward catalog. The key to effective beauty rewards is offering options that feel valuable and relevant:

• Product Rewards: Free full-size products or exclusive limited editions
• Experience Rewards: Virtual consultations, early access to launches, or VIP events
• Service Rewards: Free makeovers, personalized product recommendations, or extended consultations
• Exclusive Access: Members-only sales, beta testing opportunities, or behind-the-scenes content

Implementation strategy that actually works

Phase 1: Soft launch with your best customers. Don't launch your program to everyone at once. Start with your most engaged customers, the ones who already love your brand and will give honest feedback. This allows you to test the program mechanics, identify any issues, and gather testimonials before the full rollout.

Phase 2: Create compelling onboarding. Your program introduction needs to immediately communicate value. Charlotte Tilbury does this well by offering 10% off the first order just for signing up, plus access to exclusive content and masterclasses. The key is showing both immediate and long-term benefits.

Phase 3: Integrate across all touch points. Your rewards program shouldn't feel separate from your brand experience, it should enhance every interaction. This means:

• Website integration: Visible points balance, easy redemption, progress tracking
• Email marketing: Personalized rewards updates, milestone celebrations, exclusive offers
• Social media: Program highlights, member spotlights, exclusive community content
• In-person services: Points earning at appointments, surprise bonuses, tier recognition

Phase 4: Optimize based on data. The best loyalty programs evolve continuously. Track key metrics like enrollment rates, engagement levels, redemption patterns, and customer lifetime value. Use this data to refine earning opportunities, adjust reward values, and identify new benefits members actually want.

Advanced strategies for beauty programs

Personalization at scale: Use customer data to create personalized experiences within your rewards program. This might mean recommending rewards based on past purchases, sending birthday bonuses featuring their favorite product categories, or creating custom challenges that align with their beauty goals.

Community building through rewards transform your program from a transactional tool into a community hub. Create member forums where customers can share tips and reviews, host virtual events exclusively for program members, or develop user-generated content campaigns that reward participation.

Seasonal and limited-time activations: Keep your program fresh with rotating campaigns. Double points during new product launches, special rewards for holiday shopping, or exclusive access to limited-edition items. These activations create urgency and excitement around program participation.

Partnership integration: Consider partnerships that enhance your rewards program's value without increasing your costs. This might mean partnering with complementary beauty brands for exclusive offers, collaborating with local spas for service rewards, or working with beauty influencers for exclusive member content.

Measuring success beyond revenue

Engagement metrics: Track how often members interact with your program beyond just earning and redeeming points. High engagement indicates strong emotional connection.

Community growth: Monitor how your program affects word-of-mouth marketing, referral rates, and organic social media mentions.

Customer lifetime value: The ultimate measure of loyalty program success is whether it increases how much customers spend with you over time, not just how often they make purchases.

Retention rates: Compare customer retention between program members and non-members. The gap should be significant and growing over time.

Common pitfalls to avoid

Over-complicating the structure: If customers can't quickly understand how to earn and redeem rewards, they won't participate. Simplicity beats sophistication every time.

Undervaluing rewards: Beauty customers can do the math. If your rewards don't offer genuine value compared to competitors, your program will fail to drive engagement.

Ignoring non-purchase activities: The most successful beauty loyalty programs reward community building activities like reviews, referrals, and social engagement, not just spending.

Poor communication: Many programs fail not because they're poorly designed, but because customers don't understand their benefits or how to maximize them.

Your next steps

Creating a successful beauty rewards program isn't about copying what Sephora or Ulta does, it's about understanding what makes your customers tick and designing experiences that deepen those relationships. The brands that win in beauty aren't just those with the best products, but those that make customers feel most valued and understood.

Start by choosing one program type that aligns with your business goals, then build in community elements that reflect your brand values. Remember, the goal isn't just repeat purchases, it's creating passionate advocates who genuinely want to see your brand succeed.

In an industry where customers have unlimited options, the brands that make people feel like they truly belong will always have the competitive advantage. Your rewards program isn't just about points and perks, it's about building relationships that last.

Ready to build a loyalty program that creates genuine community and drives sustainable growth?

START FREE